Expanding a Franchise Network: Best Practices
The expansion of the franchise network refers to the transition from localized success to an ambition of national or even international deployment.
The analysis of success factors reveals a systemic approach that revolves around three fundamental pillars: the validation and preparation of the concept (I), the legal and financial structuring of the expansion (II), and finally, the operational deployment and rigorous management of the network (III).
Concept validation and preparation for expansion
Before even considering the recruitment of the first franchisee, the future franchisor must ensure that its business model is not only profitable, but also duplicable. This preparatory phase is the foundation on which the entire network architecture will be based.
The proven success of the pilot unit
The pilot unit serves as a laboratory to test, refine and optimize all processes: sales techniques, inventory management, personnel management, local marketing, etc. It is at this stage that errors are allowed and adjustments must be made. From a legal point of view, the success of the pilot unit constitutes a major commercial argument and substantial information to be presented in the Pre-contractual Information Document (PID).
Article L. 330-3 of the Commercial Code requires the franchisor to present “the state and development prospects of the market concerned”; the concrete results of the pilots are the best illustration of these prospects. The absence of a driver or the concealment of his poor results may constitute a defect of consent for the franchisee, paving the way for the nullity of the contract and damages.
Modelling and transmission of know-how
The heart of the franchise lies in the transmission of know-how. The European Block Exemption Regulation No. 2022/720 defines know-how as a set of non-patented practical information, resulting from the franchisor’s experience and tested by the franchisor, which is secret, substantial and identified:
-
Secret
- : Know-how should not be generally known or easily accessible. It confers a competitive advantage on the one who holds it.
- : It must be useful and important for the franchisee, allowing him to improve his competitive position, in particular through better management, a more attractive offer of products or services or increased efficiency
- character: The know-how must be described in a sufficiently complete manner to make it possible to verify that it meets the conditions of secrecy and substantiality.
Substantiality
Identified
This identification requires the formalization of know-how in a transmissible medium, commonly known as a “bible” or “operating manual”. This document is the cornerstone of the duplication of the concept. It must detail, with quasi-scientific precision, all operational, commercial, administrative and managerial procedures. Its drafting is a demanding exercise that forces the franchisor to analyze and rationalize its own methods.
Protection of intangible assets
The third pillar of preparation is the legal security of customer rallying signs. The brand is the most valuable asset in the network. It is imperative to ensure its availability and to file it with the INPI in the relevant product and service classes, before any development.
Beyond the trademark, other assets must be protected: domain names, architectural concepts (copyrightable), specific software (protected by copyright and/or patent), etc. A comprehensive and proactive intellectual property strategy is a non-negotiable prerequisite.
The legal and financial structuring of the expansion
Once the concept has been validated and protected, the franchisor must build the structure that will support the development of the network. This engineering phase is decisive for the scalability of the model and the legal certainty of the whole.
The choice of the franchisor’s legal structure
The franchisor must have a legal structure dedicated to the franchise activity, separate from that which operates the pilot units. This choice has major implications in terms of responsibility, taxation and credibility.
Contractual engineering of the network
Contractual documentation is the backbone of the network. It must be drafted with the greatest precision to balance the interests of the parties, ensure the homogeneity of the network and prevent litigation.
- The Pre-contractual Information Document (PID): Subject to the obligation of Article L. 330-3 of the Commercial Code, the PID must be given to the franchisee candidate at least twenty days before the signing of the contract. Its objective is to allow the candidate to make an informed commitment. It must contain sincere and complete information about the franchisor, its business, the network, the market, and the essential clauses of the contract. Any inaccurate, incomplete or omitted information, if deemed determinative of the franchisee’s consent, may result in the cancellation of the contract and/or the award of damages.
- Franchise agreement: This sui generis agreement must carefully articulate the respective obligations of the parties. Critical clauses include:
- The transmission of know-how and assistance: The contract must detail the consistency of initial training and ongoing assistance (technical, commercial, etc.), which are the counterpart of the fees.
- The financial clauses: Entry fee (remunerating network integration) and periodic fees (remunerating ongoing services and brand license) must be clearly defined in their basis and amount.
- Territorial exclusivity: This is a frequent but not essential clause. If it is granted, its scope must be defined unambiguously to avoid conflicts, especially in the era of e-commerce (“web-to-store”, “click-and-collect”).
- Procurement clauses: Exclusive or quasi-exclusive procurement clauses are lawful if they are essential to the preservation of the identity and reputation of the network. However, they are under the close supervision of competition law (Articles L. 420-1 and L. 442-1 of the French Commercial Code) and must be justified and proportionate.
- Non-competition clauses: The post-contractual non-competition clause must, to be valid, be limited in time (generally one year), in space (at the premises operated) and to the activity covered by the contract, and be justified by the protection of the know-how transmitted.
The strategy for financing growth
The expansion has a significant cost for the franchisor: structuring, recruitment, training, opening assistance, development of central services. This financing need must be anticipated. The sources can be multiple: self-financing by the results of the pilots, recourse to bank loans, or opening the capital to investors (development capital funds, business angels). A sound and transparent legal and financial structure, as well as a solid business plan detailing the expansion strategy, are prerequisites for convincing financial partners.
Operational deployment and management of the network: from strategy to execution
If the structuring phase establishes the legal and strategic foundations of the network, the deployment and management phase constitutes the test of reality. It is at this stage that the franchisor’s promise materializes and the value of the network is built on a daily basis. Faulty operational execution can wipe out the benefits of the best of preparations. Long-term success is based on sophisticated recruitment engineering, effective transmission of know-how and a subtle balance between animation and control of the
network.
Franchisee recruitment and selection engineering
Recruitment should not be understood as a simple business process aimed at “selling” franchises, but as a strategic function of selecting partner-entrepreneurs. The quality of the human mesh is the first intangible asset of the network. Rushed recruitment, often motivated by the desire to quickly cash in entry fees to finance growth, is a major strategic mistake that inevitably leads to underperformance, conflict and a degradation of brand image.
Defining the target profile and recruitment communication
The first step is to precisely define the “persona” of the ideal franchisee. Beyond financial capabilities (personal contribution, debt capacity), this profile must integrate behavioural (soft skills) and managerial skills, a real entrepreneurial spirit and, above all, an alignment with the culture and values of the brand.
Recruitment communication, although necessary, is a legally sensitive field. The case law is consistent in sanctioning franchisors who present forward-looking operating accounts or local market studies as guarantees of success. Such a practice may constitute fraud by fraudulent manoeuvres or reluctance (Article 1137 of the Civil Code), engaging the pre-contractual liability of the franchisor (Article 1112-1 of the Civil Code) and may lead to the cancellation of the contract.
Structuring the selection process
A rigorous and multi-stage selection process is the best guarantee of the quality of recruitments. It must allow for a mutual and thorough evaluation of:
-
Initial
- qualification: A first filter (telephone or videoconference) makes it possible to validate the fundamental prerequisites (project, contribution, mobility).
- Information and transparency: The submission of the Pre-contractual Information Document (PID) is a formal and crucial step, which must be accompanied by clear explanations.
- interviews: Several interviews with different interlocutors of the head of the network (developer, facilitator, management) make it possible to meet the eyes and evaluate all the facets of the application.
- day: Organizing a “discovery” day within a pilot unit is a very effective practice. It allows the candidate to confront the operational reality of the concept and the franchisor to observe the candidate “in a situation”.
- validation: The candidate must present their finalized business plan and the validation of their bank financing. This is proof of the viability of his individual entrepreneurial project.
- committee: The decision to approve a candidate must be collegial to guarantee the objectivity and commitment of the entire head of the network.
In-depth
Immersion
Project
Final validation
Initial training and assistance: the effective transmission of know-how
Initial training and assistance with opening constitute the performance of the franchisor’s main obligation: the transmission of its know-how. A breach of this obligation is a breach of an essential obligation, likely to result in the termination of the contract at the sole fault of the franchisor, with serious financial consequences (restitution of the right of entry, compensation for investments, etc.).
The initial training program
The training should be designed to transform an entrepreneur, sometimes new to the industry, into an expert on the concept. It must imperatively combine two dimensions:
- Theoretical: In the classroom, this phase aims at the appropriation of the operating manual. It covers all aspects of the business: sales techniques, purchasing and inventory management, team management, use of IT tools, financial management (mastery of key performance indicators – KPIs), and the brand’s marketing strategy.
- Practice: Immersion for several weeks in one or more pilot units is essential. The future franchisee is not just an observer; he must actively participate in all daily tasks to take ownership of business gestures and processes. This phase is often sanctioned by a final evaluation that formalizes the validation of the transfer of skills.
Opening assistance
This critical phase, which extends over several months, is a real project co-managed by the franchisor and the franchisee. The franchisor’s assistance is decisive and must cover:
- Location search assistance: The franchisor provides the selection criteria (catchment area, flow, visibility) and can validate the relevance of a premises, without however replacing the franchisee in its final decision so as not to assume responsibility for a bad choice.
- Support for setting up the project: Help with the finalization of the business plan, networking with partners (banks, insurers, referenced architects).
- The monitoring of the development: The franchisor ensures compliance with the architectural concept, guaranteeing the homogeneity of the network.
- Presence at the launch: The presence of a facilitator or trainer on site in the days before and after the opening is an essential practice to finalize the training of the teams, adjust the last details and manage the “shot” of the startup.
Network
animation and control: the delicate balance between support and monitoring
Once the point of sale is open, the franchisor-franchisee relationship enters its maturity phase. The role of the franchisor is evolving towards a dual mission: to lead to develop performance and control to protect the common value of the network.
Animation: a lever for performance and cohesion
Animation is the continuous service that justifies, in large part, the collection of periodic fees. It should not be perceived as mere supervision, but as a constant contribution of value.
- The role of the network facilitator: This is the linchpin of the relationship. He is not a line manager, but an internal consultant. Its role is to help the franchisee perform, by analysing their KPIs with them, identifying areas for progress, training them in new developments and bringing good practices from the field to the head of the network.
- Animation tools: Animation is not just about the animator’s visits. It is based on an ecosystem of communication and sharing: national conventions, regional meetings, thematic working committees (purchasing, marketing, etc.), collaborative intranet, newsletters. These tools are vital for maintaining cohesion, spreading innovation and developing collective intelligence within the network.
Control: a necessity for the sustainability of the brand
Control is not an end in itself, but the necessary means for the franchisor to fulfill its obligation to guarantee the integrity and homogeneity of its network. This control is the counterpart of the right granted to the franchisee to use a trademark that does not belong to it. It must be clearly provided for in the contract and relate to compliance with the standards of the concept (quality of products/services, layout, customer reception, etc.).
The major legal risk associated with the control is that of the reclassification of the franchise relationship into an employment contract.
Discover our related services and tools
Distribution networks, Competition
Electronic dip
Created since 2014 at the initiative of Gouache Avocats, the electronic dip has proven its worth, and allows many network heads to deliver their dip electronically, simplifying the life of developers.
Created since 2014 at the initiative of Gouache Avocats, the electronic dip has proven its worth, and allows many network heads to deliver their dip electronically, simplifying the life of developers.
Distribution networks, Competition
Choose the legal organisation of your distribution network
You created a business, invented a service, developed a product, a brand?
You want to develop a distribution network to expand your market share. You have a number of objectives in mind for this network, but you are wondering about its legal organization.
You created a business, invented a service, developed a product, a brand?
You want to develop a distribution network to expand your market share. You have a number of objectives in mind for this network, but you are wondering about its legal organization.
Réseaux de distribution, Concurrence
Update Distribution Contracts
New laws and regulations regularly change the rules applicable to your distribution contract.
Judges interpret them daily and give readings that sometimes change the solution.
These changes are permanent and require regular maintenance of your distribution contracts.
New laws and regulations regularly change the rules applicable to your distribution contract.
Judges interpret them daily and give readings that sometimes change the solution.
These changes are permanent and require regular maintenance of your distribution contracts.
Distribution networks, Competition
Drafting a franchise agreement
Want to create a franchise network? Become a Franchisor
Gouache Avocats draws up your tailor-made franchise agreement, for a sustainable and secure development of your network.
Want to create a franchise network? Become a Franchisor
Gouache Avocats draws up your tailor-made franchise agreement, for a sustainable and secure development of your network.
And resources on the same topic: "Franchise Agreement"
Réseaux de distribution, Concurrence
The legal risk associated with the issuance of market statements in the dip
Jean-Baptiste Gouache (Lawyer – Partner) Member of the College of Experts of the French Franchise Federation Market status is a point of legal risk for all brands that are required to issue a dip. To master it, it is first necessary to know what a market state is, before setting up the int…
Réseaux de distribution, Concurrence
Deductible: substantial know-how and obligation to provide assistance
The Dijon Court of Appeal refined the definition of substantial know-how, holding that the combination of public elements may be sufficient to confer a competitive advantage. The decision also delineates the franchisor's obligation to provide assistance and recalls the franchisee's duty of initiative.
Réseaux de distribution, Concurrence
Resumption of commitments and circulation of the franchise contract
The Court of Appeal of Rennes delivered an enlightening judgment on crucial points of franchise contract law concerning the terms of resumption of a franchise contract by a company in formation and the validity of its transmission within the framework of a TUP of the franchisor.
